The selection is tons of fun at Chesterton Toys. We carry books, games, puzzles, collectibles, toys for outside and so much more. Check out some of our categories below, and don’t hesitate to call us at (219) 728-3030 if you don’t see something you’re looking for. Our knowledgeable staff is here to help you find exactly what toy you want to fuel your imagination!

Infant, Toddler & Bath

Trains & Cars

Imaginative Play

Cooking, Playmobil, Timber Tots, Puppets, Magic



Products That Challenge With Science, Technology, Engineering & Math


Pops, Pez, Keychains, etc.

Great Gifts for $20 & Under

Chesterton Toys

Our Response to COVID-19

We at Chesterton Toys are going above & beyond the recommendations listed by the CDC in regards to Covid-19. Here are some actions that we are taking to ensure the public’s safety:

  • Masks MUST be worn properly inside store
  • Hand Sanitizing Stations are at entry and check-out points
  • Guests are asked to limit their touching of products & displays
  • All demo items have been removed until we feel it is safe to put them back on display 
  • Credit Card station and pens are sanitized between each transaction 
  • Staff is directed to wash hands often throughout the day
  • NO public washroom is available