A few of the Fabulous product lines you’ll find at Chesterton Toys:
You like us! You really, really like us! ❤️
We absolutely love Chesterton Toys! They’re always so nice and welcoming, plus they have a great selection of interesting toys and puzzles! They make a point to remember you, which says a lot about how much they care about their customers. If you haven’t checked them out, I highly recommend it!
I am a huge fan of toy stores and this one is top notch. The owner was personable and available. I bought way more than I budgeted, but the quality of it all, was totally worth it. Great store!
Wonderfully stocked with delightful toys, books, nostalgia and candy! It doesn't get better than this in a small town with a big heart! The owner loves what he does and it shows! This will be my first stop for any children's needs! Handicapped friendly!
SQUISHIES!!!
Chesterton Toys has proudly carried NeeDoh Brand squishies for 10+ years! In this time of unprecedented demand, we have sought out alternative brands of Squishies and Dumplings to satisfy your squishing needs. We’re sure you will love them just as much as the “real” ones!
Plushie Pals
They’re NOT “Stuffed Animals”, they’re FRIENDS! When no one else is around to give you a hug, they’re there! When you’re throwing a tea party on the fly, who’s coming? They are! Most of all, when you want something cute that matches your style, who has the best plushies around? WE DO!!!
Bath Time!
Baths can be be Fun or Relaxing and we’ve got something for every type of bath 😃
Littlest Ones ❤️ Chesterton Toys!
Our shop starts little ones out right with unique playthings that inspire thoughtful engagement, sure to build young minds and grow little hearts
Reading is “Fun-damental”!
We are HUGE Book Lovers over here! We have a little something for everyone, but are super excited when we find something truly unique ❤️
Is Your Desk Missing
A Little Something?
For Our Puzzling Peeps!
Every age can benefit from the brain boosting power of puzzling!
If You Build It, You’ll Be Done!
Model Kits have resurfaced as a beloved pastime! We have many themes and carry both Snap Together and Paint & Glue styles
Come for the Toys, stay for the LOVE….
Official Drop-Off Location for U.S. Marine Toys for Tots!
The objectives of the Marines Toys for Tots Foundation are to help economically disadvantaged children throughout the United States experience...
For the Love of a Small Town
Chesterton’s heart is in its Small Businesses. We are home to very few chains and ZERO “Big Box” stores. We...
Indiana Dunes National Park
Lake Michigan’s southernmost tip is home to the Jewel of Northwest Indiana - Indiana Dunes National Park. This park houses...